Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sax's avatar
3dEdited

Her take on the Sambia (which she calls the Simbari?) seems pretty uninformed. Studies suggest that intimidation and fear of castration as a key element of this ritualized manhood — in other words trauma as integral to the experience.

While the term trauma or how we understand it in our culture might not be part of the language, differ or just not exist as a concept in another culture doesn’t equate that trauma wasn’t experienced.

Not being able to name the traumatic moment or any kind of emotional experience doesn’t mean it hasn’t happened.

Furthermore, WILD she would suggest that because members of this tribe who went through this ritual cause their own children to go through this that they must not experience trauma?!! Because surely those who experienced severe trauma never put their children or loved ones through similar experiences lmfao

Her argument could also be used to suggest FGM as a normal non-traumatic experience irregardless that many women in these cultures want and are resisting it.

I feel like Joshua is smarter than half these guests and he asks really interesting, often complex questions with a genuine curiosity but because of this sometimes the interviews fall flat because the answers by guests are so lacking and uninformed comparatively.

But I do understand that to also be the point. It seems more like a research project in that sense. But some more compelling than others.

Expand full comment
Venture Studios's avatar

I’m completely captivated.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts