Literally every link from the Twitch stream in 2023

Wishing you all a very happy 2024! This is our year and we’re all gonna make it (screenshot this).

I started Twitch streaming in 2020. A big part of this project has been sorting out the signal from noise amidst the chaos of extremely online culture. Many memes, posts and think pieces are dismissable content but some of them matter a lot. In fact, some of them indicate important political and cultural shifts that could otherwise be overlooked.

In the spirit of this project, I’m sharing a giant list of links from every Twitch stream in 2023. I've highlighted the most interesting and impactful links that (to me) represent an early indication of larger shifts in politics, media and culture.

First, here are my year-end best recommendations:

• NEW MODELS
  Holographic Media (2023)
  — NM chronicles the fading of legacy media & the emergence of the online “dark forest”, in concert with Yancey Strickler, Maggie Appleton,
  Venkatesh Rao
  Peter N Limberg

• Catherine Liu
  What is Trauma in a Digital Age? (2021)
  — lecture at the UNE Center for Global Humanities. Catherine is as insightful as ever. The Q&A is especially incisive and she defends her thesis masterfully.
  

• Angela Nagle
  The Washington Consensus is Dead (2023)
  — this article summarizes Angela’s longer series on Substack about “the Industrial Policy Renaissance”. The Chips Act, the Infrastructure Act and the Inflation Reduction Act all represent a significant break with the US neoliberal consensus.
  

• Vincent Bevins: How Protest Movements Fall Apart (2023)
  — a history of the 2010’s social media inflected mass protest movements which (spoiler alert) failed. Bevin’s critique of horizontalism and the New Left is especially relevant today.
  

• Peter Turchin: Is The West Heading Towards Social Breakdown? (2023)
  — Turchin’s historical analysis spans several centuries. He uses wealth inequality as an overall indicator and predictor of social unrest and eventually revolution. His work is discussed on both the left and right. His research is not ideological but rigorously historical.

Twitch Stream 2023 links:

https://dis.art/the-metaverse-in-janky-capitalism

Josh Kline on the unfolding disasters of climate change and AI | Under the Cover

Alex Jones: NWO WARS Video Game Official Trailer

The Techno-Optimist Manifesto | Andreessen Horowitz

The Left Youtube Pipeline - The Good, The Bad, and The Hot

https://www.forbes.com/sites/saibala/2023/11/08/amazon-announces-new-benefit-for-prime-members-primary-care-services-for-9-per-month/?sh=6df7dbc37aca

JJ McCullough | Pushing on an open door

https://www.theguardian.com/info/2023/nov/15/removed-document

Twee Whistler: Internet Core

TikTok's biggest artit freaks out, attacks mild art critic

TikTok Star Devon Rodriguez Is Now the Most Famous Artist in the World. But What About His Work?

The World’s Most Popular Painter Sent His Followers After Me Because He Didn’t Like a Review of His Work. Here’s What I Learned

Art in the After-Culture

dis — Spooky Castle

How Mass Protests Fall Apart | Ash Sarkar Meets Vincent Bevins

‍Sara Bezovšek & Dorijan Šiško: What’s Your Truth

Watch the film the Israel lobby didn't want you to see | The Electronic Intifada

The Lobby - USA, episode 1

The Lobby - USA, episode 2

The Lobby - USA, episode 3

The Lobby - USA, episode 4

https://litreactor.com/columns/book-vs-films-invasion-of-the-body-snatchers

https://archive.org/details/invasionofthebodysnatchers1956_201911

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Pisacane

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F-scale_(personality_test)

The F Scale: Final form

https://www.gamescenes.org/2023/10/event-the-seashore-of-endless-worlds-november-1-19-2023-geneva-switzerland.html

The Techno-Optimist Manifesto | Andreessen Horowitz

Announcing 𒋧 Kudurru

Pure Pwnage finale

https://www.ima.org.au/ima-events/book-launch-do-not-research/

https://joshuacitarella.substack.com/p/platform-wars-part-4-a-public-option?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

RFK Jr.: Both parties are controlled and paralyzed

Pure Pwnage episode 11 - "i heart u in rl" [original web series]

Artist Rachel Rossin on the Journey to Self-Creation | Louisiana Channel

Debating Vaush, Emma Vigeland And Ryan Grim At The White House

https://progressivevictory.win/

Pure Pwnage episode 8 - "Lanageddon" [original web series]

Pure Pwnage episode 9 - "The Story of Dave" [original web series]

Is The West Heading Towards Social Breakdown? | Aaron Bastani Meets Peter Turchin | Downstream

Pure Pwnage web series soundtrack - "I feel like pwning noobs"

Well-known conservative shares his conversion story - ENN 2019-03-01

Woke Is Dying—Long Live the New Center | Compact Mag

How the GOP Can Mend Fences With Unions | Compact Mag

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sohrab_Ahmari

The Conservative Split Over ‘Drag Queen Story Hour’ | Sohrab Ahmari

RIGHT Populist CALLS OUT 'Fake' Anti-Woke Populists | Breaking Points

I Was Wrong: The GOP Will Never Be the Party of the Working Class | Opinion

A "Right-Wing" Socialist? (ft. Sohrab Ahmari)

Sohrab Ahmari vs. Chris Cutrone at Columbia

https://joshuacitarella.substack.com/p/platform-wars-part-3-tiktok-and-geopolitics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pure_Pwnage

Pure Pwnage episode 4 - "Pwn or Be Pwned" [original web series]

Pure Pwnage episode 6 - "Imapwnu of Azeroth"

World of Warcraft Documentary

Sara Bezovšek: The Influencing Machine

Interactive Media Bias Chart

Donald Trump voters told us why billionaires have too much power. We v... | john russell | TikTok

China's 'indoctrination' of American schools to make 'Little Red Classrooms': Communist Party funneled $17 MILLION into more than 143 K-12 schools - sparking a Republican probe

Trump Rally Goers HATE Billionaires Too | Breaking Points

Inventing New Sexualities

Is The West Heading Towards Social Breakdown? | Aaron Bastani Meets Peter Turchin | Downstream

How To Prepare for Imminent War - PART 1: The First 3 Priorities

https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/on-energy/2011/09/14/abiotic-oil-a-theory-worth-exploring

https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/pgfx6b/cmv_oil_is_abiotic_and_is_not_a_fossil_fuel/

https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Cassini-Huygens/Titan_s_surface_organics_surpass_oil_reserves_on_Earth

https://www.petroleum.co.uk/abiotic-oil-formation

https://phys.org/news/2019-04-rewriting-textbook-fossil-fuels-technologies.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/01/science/flames-chimaera-turkey-methane.html

https://www.forbes.com/2008/11/13/abiotic-oil-supply-energenius08-biz-cz_rl_1113abiotic.html?sh=25f151d13f9e

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenic_petroleum_origin#:~:text=The%20abiotic%20hypothesis%20is%20that,the%20crust%20until%20they%20escape

https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-fossil-fuel-rockefeller/fact-check-the-term-fossil-fuel-was-not-coined-by-john-d-rockefeller-to-trick-people-into-thinking-oil-is-a-scarce-commodity-idUSL1N2QQ1UK

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_process

https://educate-yourself.org/cn/davemcgowanstalinandabioticoil05mar05.shtml

#384 | Peter Turchin: Elites and the Path to Political Disintegration - The Realignment Podcast

Friedrich Schiller's Republic Of Art And Truth

https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Doofi&page=6

https://incels.wiki/w/Oofy_doofy_theory

https://twitter.com/popcrave/status/1687495768574144512?s=46&t=MahApi9viZqXEHgnLgJ68g

​​

unbind__your__mind

A post shared by @unbind__your__mind

https://x.com/populismupdates/status/1690962271164596224?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fxb5lwh9oioc31.jpg

Eileen Isagon Skyers: In the age of AI art, what can originality look like? | TED Talk

Explaining The Irony Compass

The Densest City on Earth

Watch CNBC's full interview with Democratic Presidential Nominee Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Timcast - Only Ever Wanted (Official Music Video)

Pieter Schoolwerth, Phil Vanderhyden & Aaron Dilloway: PuppetWarp

Book Launch: August 10th at Dunkunsthalle, NYC

How to Be an Artist When Nothing Lasts Forever

FWB FEST '23 - SATURDAY LIVESTREAM

https://teamster.org/2023/07/weve-changed-the-game-teamsters-win-historic-ups-contract/

Twee Whistler: Internet Core

https://hyperallergic.com/835630/moma-trustee-leon-black-accused-of-raping-teenager/

https://twitter.com/babygravy9/status/1682799348571152384?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://store.donotresearch.net/

The Neo-Amish Movement: How To Preserve Tradition in a Technological World – Gab News

I'm Trans

a few words about ted kaczynski

Up Next

Is America Too Racist for Social Democracy? — Touré Reed

https://www.youtube.com/live/PpNUNHpOCq0?feature=share

Exercise Machines are Not Fraud

Zuckerberg's "Threads" Acknowledges It Wants No Politics Or News On Its New Twitter

Violent videos are taking over Twitter

Musk BANS Twitter users from reading more than 600 tweets a day

How Gab Deals With Scraping on the Open Web

Highlights from CPI Weekend Workshop in Missouri

new.New Festival 2016: From the Sovereign Individual to the Targeted Individual

Jen Pan, Cale Brooks: How Should History Inform Our Politics?

Anna Ørberg: Algorithms Anonymous

Statement of Aims - The Mont Pelerin Society

More On The Industrial Policy Renaissance

Charlotte Free's New York Haul

The Shein influencer trip is just the beginning

Jordan Peterson, RFK JR Interview Taken Down From YT Over Transgender Teen Convo: Report

https://www.instagram.com/patrissimo42/

Anarcho-capitalism | David D. Friedman

DIY government: “Micro-countries” are the future | Patri Friedman for Heretics

Does America Really Redistribute More Than Europe?

Exit Politics - John McAfee / Judd Weiss Libertarian Presidential Campaign Ad

https://artreview.com/ai-art-and-the-problem-of-consent/

https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/can-democracy-survive-polycrisis-artificial-intelligence-climate-change-ukraine-war-by-george-soros-2023-06

Why do we have crooked teeth when our ancestors didn’t? - G. Richard Scott

My first live show out of context (Jreg's Theory Of Everything)

Online politics is annoying

GLOBAL ART FORUM 16: UNDERSTANDING PREDICTING MEDIA

Ted kaczynski | '' I'll be dead by dawn''

A Guide to Understanding the Hoax of the Century - Tablet Magazine

The Washington consensus is dead - New Statesman

brothercornelwest

A post shared by @brothercornelwest

https://twitter.com/CornelWest/status/1665743761551548416?s=20

Trump MAULS DeSantis In Mocking Videos | Breaking Points

Ranking Modern-Day Occupations

On The E-Girl Army Psyop Phenomenon

Why Postmodernism Was a Huge Intellectual Step Back

RedBallon.work

Why I'm Excited About The Industrial Policy Renaissance

Athene's Theory of Everything

Hello there farmer - MAGAcommunism music video

The Right Stuff: Dating Right

Scarce Labor As The Cause Of Innovation

https://dis.art/the-metaverse-in-janky-capitalism

Josh Kline on the unfolding disasters of climate change and AI | Under the Cover

Jen Pan: Higher Education Culture Wars

Catherine Liu - What is Trauma in a Digital Age? (w/Q&A)

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e07 END "Marx forever" 1080p (субтитры)

https://outland.art/new-models-holographic-media/

https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1653449321185169409?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://www.ted.com/talks/noah_raford_how_gaming_can_be_a_force_for_good?language=en

Gen Z Mythmaking

6 Christians vs 1 Secret Atheist | Odd Man Out

All Christian denominations explained in 12 minutes

Finkelstein v. Dershowitz, Debate Part 2

https://watch.plex.tv/movie/immortality-or-bust

THE STAR RACES - THE FALL OF HUMANITY

https://twitter.com/trevorpaglen/status/1653736169752997891?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

Philip Guston's Cancellation

https://news.gab.com/2023/04/its-time-to-burn-the-ships-of-traditional-media/

https://twitter.com/babygravy9/status/1644703978410704896?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

Poll: Zoomers RAGE Against Political Elites | Breaking Points

Jreg: Female Archetype Tier List

Male Archetype Tier List

All Christian denominations explained in 12 minutes

Norman Finkelstein VS Alan Dershowitz - A Lively Debate on Democracy Now

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e06 "First International" 1080p (субтитры)

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e05 "Great work Das Kapital" 1080p (субтитры)

https://blog.parler.com/conservative-girl-shopping-guide/

The Regime’s War To Make Memes Illegal – Gab News

Biden PROSECUTES Anti-Hillary Meme Poster | Breaking Points

Anti-Hillary Meme Lord CONVICTED By Biden | Breaking Points

How to dress your age, with Gavin McInnes

The Five Phases Of Pluto In Aquarius

An American Utopia: Fredric Jameson in Conversation with Stanley Aronowitz

Pentagon Plans WIDESPREAD Spying On Chat Rooms After Leak | Breaking Points

Dennis Rodman’s Big Bang in Pyongyang (2015)

https://therokuchannel.roku.com/watch/38e51d660abe52bb802e6d7a1ec77204?source=google

https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B07HS2VL8H/ref=atv_dp_share_cu_r

https://tubitv.com/movies/327021/dennis-rodmans-big-bang-in-pyongyang?start=true&utm_source=google-feed&tracking=google-feed

https://ideosorter.github.io/index.html?en

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e04 "Scientific socialism shines brightly" 1080p (субтитры)

https://twitter.com/simonehcollins/status/1639658069318574080?s=46&t=sRm9X0ySQDH0i3BM1AEqbg

https://twitter.com/simonehcollins/status/1640028250796617728?s=46&t=sRm9X0ySQDH0i3BM1AEqbg

https://www.businessinsider.com/pronatalism-elon-musk-simone-malcolm-collins-underpopulation-breeding-tech-2022-11

Marianne Williamson SHREDS Biden, AOC, Talks 2024 Primary | Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar

Elon STRIPS NY Times Of Blue Checkmark | Breaking Points

Notes on e/acc principles and tenets

https://jacob.energy/hyperstructures.html

Forbidden Expression

"Progressivism, Socialism, Nationalism": Socialism and Its Agenda

https://twitter.com/blkhmmrtimes/status/1638004116105428992?s=46

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/02/16/pers-f16.html

https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1636429773865095168?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1638380944284585985?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1638731349489238017?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

Krystal And Saagar DEBATE: Should TikTok Be BANNED | Breaking Points

Glenn Greenwald: Calls To BAN TikTok Are A DISTRACTION; Elites Blame CCP For Problems THEY CAUSED

Booty Bay Open Studios

Pre-Emptively Coming Out As A Robophobe

The Three Phases of Culture

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e03 "New world view" 1080p (субтитры)

https://twitter.com/babygravy9/status/1636415782136729601?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://www.instagram.com/kazakhmarxist/reels/

https://twitter.com/bobdunlap9477/status/1635572226329047043?s=46&t=jW_xfAX0j6Fjiv2ObgRGRg

https://twitter.com/_anna_joy_/status/1637480026190004224?s=20

Nelk Boys Instagram

https://flash---art.com/article/based-it-girl/#

UO Today interview: Whitney Phillips, Digital Platforms and Ethics

All the “wellness” products Americans love to buy are sold on both Infowars and Goop

'Ranking Member Plaskett, I'm Not A So-Called Journalist': Matt Taibbi Discusses The Twitter Files

​​​​

https://twitter.com/lakefieldmoscow/status/1632956808485650432?s=20

Lt. Gov. Randy McNally apologizes over Instagram controversy

Anti-LGBTQ Tennessee Lt. Gov. McNally Comments On Racy Instagram Pics of Young Gay Male

Trump DOMINATES CPAC: 'I AM YOUR RETRIBUTION' | Breaking Points

Expanded Virgin Vs. Chad Lore

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e02 "Defending the rights of the people" 1080p

Introducing Gabby: Our Friendly AI Bot That Generates Amazing Images – Gab News

Why The Worldview of The People Building AI Matters

SeaBrick, Better and Less Expensive than Concrete, It’s Eco Restorative and Sequesters CO2

https://twitter.com/GynoHaz/status/1627540981955588096?s=20

https://twitter.com/RealCPIUSA/status/1624090828380549128?s=20

https://twitter.com/RealCPIUSA

President of Mexico nationalizes lithium - Green Car Congress

https://twitter.com/infrahaz/status/1628108195666198531?s=46&t=vQWImWGHNX-toEW1ZXNOcg

You Voted Trump! Joy Behar BLAMES Ohioans for Derailment | Breaking Points

Nina Turner STUNS CNN, SLAMS Joy Behar For Shaming Ohio Residents

Vice News: Why the US Power Grid is Under Attack

Did Slavery Drive the US Economy? – James Oakes

Updating Human Relationships For Current Year

You're Not An Introvert; You're Just Mentally Deranged

Poshi: reading islamic philosophy??

Future Shock Documentary (1972)

Raindrops Keep Falling on My Head SMV (Soyjak Music Video) feat. Feraljak

Lab Leak Most Likely Caused Pandemic, Energy Dept. Says - The New York Times

If the Wuhan lab-leak hypothesis is true, expect a political earthquake | Thomas Frank | The Guardian

US Government ADMITS Lab Leak COVID Origin | Breaking Points

https://twitter.com/TVietor08/status/1629866904721719296

Learning To Be Alone

My Dad, the Facebook Addict (2019)

领风者 / The Leader / Вождь s01e01 "Different youth" 1080p (субтитры)

https://twitter.com/aeonanimus/status/1625351099782770690?s=46&t=Mo7zBCoUWhKaAoMA_-qEfw

https://blog.parler.com/top-10-memes/?mtm_campaign=emailnewsletter&mtm_source=emailnewsletter021623&mtm_medium=email

DEATH OF A YUPPIE DREAM

Incelclopedia: A Glossary Of Incel Terms

“Sun Your Balls” (it's primal AF)

God Creates The Verts

Inside the 40 Year-Long Dungeons & Dragons Game | Obsessed | WIRED

Capitalism: A Debate — Reason vs Jacobin

https://twitter.com/mr_unspeakable/status/1623400513893965830?s=46&t=u3Hser5CG_qO004zjvBa6w

https://twitter.com/lauren_southern/status/1623103441844436992?s=46&t=7NIVLMYCpbPXupdxbZPxWA

Tucker: Airbnb goes full North Korea

https://twitter.com/trueanonpod/status/1623382106704412673?s=46&t=vQioSSvTxO1E2t8CBlyunw

Henry Kissinger Tribute Video

EVERY ANGEL IS TERRIFYING

Dr. Anthony Chaffee - 'Plants are trying to kill you!'

https://www.etvbharat.com/amp/english/national/state/chhattisgarh/maoists-behead-bjp-leader-neelkanth-kakkem-in-front-of-his-kin-in-chhattisgarh/na20230205193129849849368

Meet the Left-Wing German Politician Drawing Support from the Right

https://rumble.com/v27rlj8-system-update-31.html

https://www.twitch.tv/watchmeforever

https://twitter.com/autismcapital/status/1622665348578439170?s=46&t=_y5klbj_LNF3xOsMyZd4EA

Socialist Policies Explained | Bhaskar Sunkara and Lex Fridman

The Oakville Incident - Real Mysteries

The Bizarre Oakville “Blob Rain” Incident

Has the Number of Sexless Young Men Really Increased a Lot?

How It's Made - Canola Oil

Dr. Chris Knobbe - 'Diseases of Civilization: Are Seed Oil Excesses the Unifying Mechanism?'

How corrupt is our government | Bhaskar Sunkara and Lex Fridman

https://blog.parler.com/what-is-the-parler-community-jury/?mtm_campaign=emailnewsletter&mtm_source=emailnewsletter012623&mtm_medium=email

https://twitter.com/loffredojeremy/status/1619786795943710721?s=20&t=GI2lr5bfQP8BfzChZ6v89w

https://twitter.com/JoshuaCitarella/status/1620093263742115841

Extraordinary Until Proven Otherwise

u/akira

"Be A Man”: Modernists and Traditionalists Debate Masculinity | VICE Debates

Race & Class After American Segregation — Adolph Reed Jr. (FULL INTERVIEW) LIST

https://news.gab.com/2023/01/conservative-inc-and-the-deal-with-the-daily-wire-devil/

https://twitter.com/alpacaaurelius/status/1614253561583484928?s=46&t=aQrQ4AnUpimkESq0PaowJQ

do.not.research

A post shared by @do.not.research

https://store.donotresearch.net/

Inside the Wellness Festival for Millionaires | Fringes

NEW DATA: Is Peter Zeihan Right About China? | Breaking Points

Dena Yago: "First + Second Impressions"

SINO GANGSTALKING APOCALYPSE

I predicted the ‘vibe shift’ – and watched it sweep the world. Here’s what it actually means | Fashion | The Guardian

“Incels” are not particularly right-wing or white, but they are extremely depressed, anxious, and lonely, according to new research>

https://twitter.com/lhfang/status/1605292454261182464?s=46&t=cgV5-46g0BExJWaxyBXIkg

This Place Rules (Official Trailer)

Q Family (This Place Rules)

Election Day (This Place Rules)

The Day Joe Biden Won

The First Stop the Steal Rally

The Democratic electorate's seismic shift

Jreg: Self Help

Poshi: women's american psycho? 😱🔪 (my year of rest and relaxation)

Resume: New Models – The Future of Critique (26.11.22)